Essays On Utilitarian Theory Nursing

Ethics in Nursing Essay

1925 Words8 Pages

Deontology vs. Utilitarianism
Deontology is an ethical theory concerned with duties and rights. The founder of deontological ethics was a German philosopher named Immanuel Kant. Kant’s deontological perspective implies people are sensitive to moral duties that require or prohibit certain behaviors, irrespective of the consequences (Tanner, Medin, & Iliev, 2008). The main focus of deontology is duty: deontology is derived from the Greek word deon, meaning duty. A duty is morally mandated action, for instance, the duty never to lie and always to keep your word. Based on Kant, even when individuals do not want to act on duty they are ethically obligated to do so (Rich, 2008).
Kant believed consequences were irrelevant and an…show more content…

Kant believed duties were absolute and unconditional and called them categorical imperatives. A categorical imperative is all people have a “perfect” duty in that if their actions were universalized, there would be no contraindications. An example is you came to a fork in the road and you had to make a decision to either go left or right. Whatever decision you made at that moment in time, you would have to make it a law by universalizing it. A nursing example would be a 19 year old girl was in the critical care unit in the hospital and is terrified. Hospital policy states they only allow visit every three hours for five minutes in the critical care unit. The girl is begging the nurse to allow her parents to stay with her. The nurse follows deontology, and will not allow the parents to stay because it is against the rules.
In contrast with deontology, there is utilitarianism, which is a consequentialist theory. Utilitarianists consider consequences to be an important indicator of the moral value of one’s actions (Rich, 2008). In consequentialist analyses, conclusions about what is right or wrong are based on the consequences (Tanner et al., 2008). Utilitarianism is to promote the greatest good for the greatest amount of people that is possible in situations.
Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart

Show More

Deontology And Utilitarianism: Ethical Theories For Nurses

Deontology and Utilitarianism: Ethical Theories for Nurses
Ethics is not a concept that is thought about often, but it is practiced on a daily basis. Even while unconscious of the fact, people consider ethics while making every choice in life. There are many theories to which people allude, but two radically different theories that are sometimes practiced are deontology and utilitarianism. Deontology deals with actions in a situation while utilitarianism examines the consequences of those actions. While polar opposites on the broad spectrum of ethics, deontology and utilitarianism are bioethical theories that can be applied to nursing practice and personal life situations.
Kant’s Deontology
German philosopher Immanuel Kant popularized the philosophy of deontology, which is described as actions that are based on obligation rather than personal gain or happiness (Rich & Butts, 2014). While developing his theory, Kant deemed two qualities that are essential for an action to be deemed an ethical. First, he believed it was never acceptable to sacrifice freedom of others to achieve a desired goal. In other words, he believed in equal respect for all humans. Each human has a right for freedom and justice, and if an action takes away the freedom of another, it is no longer ethical or morally correct. Secondly, he held that good will is most important, and that what is good is not determined by the outcome of the situation but by the action made (Johnson, 2008). In short, he simply meant that the consequences of a situation do not matter, only the intention of an action. Kant also declared that for an act to be considered morally correct, the act must be driven by duty alone. By extension, there could be no other motivation such as love, family, or lust. Finally, Kant stated that an action must be absolute in order to be deemed morally correct (Rich & Butts, 2014). In other words, an act must be able to be applied to all situations to be seen as acceptable. Like the Golden Rule, a person should not perform an act that he would not want done to himself such as infidelity, lying, or stealing. While most consider these examples to be negative behaviors, is it safe to say that these should be an absolute? Kant stated that for an action to be considered moral, it had to be an absolute truth (Johnson, 2008). With Kant, if a parent told a child that Santa was real, which technically is a lie, or if someone lied about a surprise birthday party, it would be considered a horrible act.
On the other hand, utilitarianism, or teleology, consists of the concept that an action or deed is weighed by the amount of goodness or happiness it produces (Rich & Butts, 2014). Basically, no action or rule is considered morally wrong or right until it is weighted against the amount of pleasure it created. Where deontology focused on the action of a situation, teleology is primarily concerned with the consequences of the action. One of its famous promoters,...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more


2143 words - 9 pages Several business organizations encounter challenges because of unethical behaviors of their employees that are against the expected norms. According to Paul and Paul (2005), ethical theories lay emphasis on the various features of an ethical problem that lead to getting the appropriate solution in relation to the theory’s stipulated guidelines. Normally, workers base their personal choice of the ethical theories in accordance with their life...

Compare and Contrast two ethical theories.

2167 words - 9 pages In this essay I have chosen to compare two opposing theories, Immanuel Kant's absolutist deontological ethics and Joseph Fletchers relativist situation ethics. The deontological ethics focuses on actions made according to duty and the categorical imperative - which shows how acts are intrinsically good or bad. The situation ethics...

Finding an Educational Standard for Nursing Students and Practicing Nurses

1444 words - 6 pages With the demand for nurses at an all-time high and more individuals entering the nursing profession, the question must be posed of what the educational standard for students entering the nursing profession should be? Although this debate has been prevalent for some time, the rising demand for registered nurses resurfaces the question with more emphasis and urgency than ever. While associates degree in nursing (ADN) programs made up roughly 60% of...

Pocket Digital Assistants And Use For Staff Nurses

3074 words - 12 pages The personal digital assistant (PDA) is a handheld device originally designed as personal organizers but over the years have advanced becoming the newest tool in the academic toolbox. It had broad capabilities is a powerful reference source as well as a computer and communicator that can be stored in a pocket. ...

The Golden Rule in Kant and Mill’s Ethical Theories

1615 words - 6 pages Ethics refers to what people consider good or bad and right or wrong. It is a theory dealing with values that relate to human behaviour; with respect to their actions and purpose. The two most important philosophers that deal with ethics are Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill. Kant’s ethical theory is Kantianism or deontological ethics. Mill’s ethical theory is utilitarianism. Both philosophers’ theories have many differences; Kant’s theory...

Varying Rationales and Ethical Frameworks for Punishment

2123 words - 8 pages What would the criminal justice system be without punishment? Perhaps, the criminal justice system would not serve a function or cease to exist. Punishment is one of the main facets of the criminal justice system. It holds such significance that it even reflects the beliefs and values of a particular society. Fyodor Dostoyevsky (1821-1881) once said “The degree of civilization in a society can be judged by entering its prisons.” (Pollock, 2010:...

Liability and Punishment for CEO's - Ethical Considerations

1688 words - 7 pages In today’s world, CEO’s of major corporations or organizations have tremendous pressure on them to meet expectations and succeed. They are responsible for making the toughest decisions that affect many people. CEO’s often struggle with decisions because personal successes and morals confront each other. Normative ethics are important for CEO’s because their actions have an effect on people’s lives. Recently,

Pros and Cons of the 12-Hour Work Schedule for Nurses

1018 words - 4 pages Hello to 12 hours, Good-bye to Sleep Imagine a nurse who has to go to work for 12 hours and how much energy he or she puts in? It feels like a never ending story and the character begins to exhaust his or her energy. As much as 12 hours may seem, the 12 hours spent in something one like to do would make it better. It may involve less sleep for someone who works 12 hours. Nurses in the past and today have been working 12 hour shifts or more,...

Learning Theories and Implications for Educational Technology

1629 words - 7 pages Learning Theories and Implications for Educational Technology Abstract The theories of Vygotsky, Gardner, and Gagne present vary different models of learning. Vygotsky and Gardner see culture as an important factor in how a child learns, and see growth and development and individual thing. Gagne, however, focuses on a formal model of instruction, with the method used depending upon the content being taught. All three theories have a role...

Theories and Principles for Planning and Enabling Learning

2630 words - 11 pages I will explain the psychology of learning and the theories I use in my practice. Analysing these theories and teaching methods will give rise, to investigating how these will help in teaching and learning ‘In a nutshell, a principle is a value, belief or ethic relating to something you do and the theory is that which explains why it works’.(Wilson 2009:350) In delivering of a lessons, educator must keep in mind SMARTER objectives. Investigating...

Theories and Principles for Planning and Enabling Learning

2348 words - 9 pages In this essay, I will identify the main tenets of Behaviourism, Cognitive and Humanist and state how each claims learning happens. I will analyse two principles and how they affect the way we plan and deliver learning. Furthermore, I will reflect on the impact of these insights on my own practice and professional development. Behaviourism main theorist included Skinner, Pavlov and Thorndike who describes this theory as having a ‘stimulus and...

0 thoughts on “Essays On Utilitarian Theory Nursing”


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *